The Pagan Origins of Christmas

The Pagan Origins of Christmas

It's easy to feel like a party crasher at Christmas if you're a witch. The tinsel goes up, the carols start looping in every grocery store, and somebody's aunt reminds everyone about the "reason for the season."

Plot twist! The evergreen tree, the holly, the mistletoe, the roaring log, the bearded gift-giver flying through the night sky... Our pagan ancestors were doing almost all of it way before Coca-Cola got ahold of the holiday. So grab some cozy tea, and let's reveal the magick behind the season.

Midwinter & the Winter Solstice

The winter solstice, around December 21 in the Northern Hemisphere, is the darkest day of the year. To ancient Europeans, it meant the worst of winter was behind them, and every day after would get a little brighter. It was also one of the only times all year people had fresh meat (cattle were slaughtered so they didn't need feeding through winter) and freshly fermented wine and beer. The party planned itself.

Quick vocab check: "pagan" started as a catch-all label early Christians slapped on anyone outside their faith. Basically, it meant "not one of us." We've since claimed it with pride.

Saturnalia: Rome's Week of Glorious Chaos

If you think your office holiday party gets wild, meet Saturnalia. Starting around December 17, Romans honored Saturn, the god of agriculture, with roughly a week of feasting, public gambling, colorful clothes, and closed businesses. The social order flipped, too: enslaved people were treated as equals for the festival, sometimes even served by the households that held them.

Saturnalia also crowned a mock king to preside over the merrymaking, a role that later resurfaced in medieval Christmas as the "Lord of Misrule." And by the 4th century, Romans were marking December 25 as the birthday of Sol Invictus, the "Unconquered Sun."

Yule: Fire, Feasting, and the Wild Hunt

The Norse and other Germanic peoples celebrated Yule around the solstice. Families burned a massive log and feasted for as long as it lasted, which could be up to 12 days. Every spark was believed to be a new piglet or calf in the coming year. Talk about manifesting! The boar was sacred to Freyr, so if your family insists on a holiday ham, you're honoring him whether you meant to or not.

But Yule wasn't all cozy firelight. Odin was said to ride the midwinter sky at night in the Wild Hunt, deciding who would thrive and who would perish in the year ahead. Plenty of folks wisely stayed inside. The Anglo-Saxons also kept Mōdraniht, or Mother's Night, honoring ancestral mothers and feminine deities. Mōdraniht actually begins the official 12 days of Yule.

Other cultures lit up the dark, too. The Sámi honored Beiwe, a sun goddess who traveled the sky with her reindeer (somebody definitely borrowed that aesthetic), and the Slavs marked Karachun by feasting with their dead and lighting fires to keep their ancestors warm. Whoever rebranded winter as merry and bright never read about its legends.

Your Decorations Are Pagan

The tree: Evergreens stayed green when everything else died back, making them a living symbol of endurance and eternal life. Romans decked their homes with greenery during Saturnalia, and Germanic peoples, who revered the World Tree Yggdrasil, decorated trees in honor of their gods. The modern Christmas tree came later, from Germany, but its roots (pun fully intended) run deep.

Holly and mistletoe: Romans gifted holly wreaths for luck during Saturnalia. The Druids saw mistletoe as sacred and protective, and lore says enemies who met beneath it would lay down their weapons and call a truce.

Caroling: Door-to-door singing comes from wassailing, from the Old English waes hael, or "be well." Revelers carried spiced ale from house to house, singing to their neighbors and chasing off bad luck for the year ahead. It's basically a community-wide protection spell!

Santa Claus: The Christian thread is St. Nicholas, a generous 4th-century bishop whose Dutch nickname, Sinterklaas, became "Santa Claus." An 1822 poem gave him reindeer, and cartoonist Thomas Nast drew his jolly look in 1881. (Coca-Cola just popularized it in a lot of ads.) But many witches see an older figure under that red suit: Odin, the long-bearded All-Father who rode the winter sky on his eight-legged horse, Sleipnir. One popular folk theory even says children left boots of straw for Sleipnir and woke to find gifts inside.

How December 25 Got Claimed

The earliest Christians didn't make a big deal of Jesus's birthday. Easter was their main event, and the Bible never names a birth date. That changed in the 4th century, when Pope Julius I helped formalize December 25.

The popular explanation is that the Church set Christmas right on top of the solstice festivals to make conversion easier. People were going to party in late December anyway, so why not rebrand the party? The catch: the Church got the date, but the people kept their bonfires, feasting, greenery, and chaos.

The Time the Puritans Canceled Christmas

For centuries, Christmas was a rowdy, boozy free-for-all, complete with a Lord of Misrule (there he is again!). The Puritans were not having it. Oliver Cromwell's government canceled Christmas in England in 1645, and Boston outlawed it from 1659 to 1681, partly because it had way too many pagan fingerprints.

In the 1800s, writers like Washington Irving and Charles Dickens repackaged it as a cozy, family-centered holiday, and by 1870, it was a U.S. federal holiday. The wild pagan party got tucked into a nice cardigan, but it never completely disappeared.

Reclaiming the Season: Bring the Old Magick Home

You don't have to choose between Christmas and your craft. Try weaving the old magick back in:

  • Burn a Yule log. Write your intentions for the coming year on a log (or a big candle) and burn it on the solstice. (Never leave a burning candle unattended!)
  • Hold a solstice vigil. Keep candles lit through the longest night, then greet the sunrise.
  • Hang mistletoe with purpose. Charge a sprig for protection and peace, then hang it over your doorway.
  • Go wassailing. Pour spiced cider at the roots of your favorite tree, or toast your besties' good health. Off-key singing is highly encouraged.
  • Honor your ancestors. Light a candle for those who came before you, and share their stories.

The light always comes back. That's the oldest message of the season, and it belongs to all of us.

Stay Magickal!
Megan W.

Posted on by Megan Winkler